Become a Partner

We’re here to help! Call now:

1-844 (566-7639)
shape

E-2 Visa Success in 2025 Business Plans & Marginality Requirement Tips

Updated 03.11.25 • 4 minutes read
US ImmigrationE-2

The E-2 investor visa continues to be one of the most popular options for entrepreneurs seeking to start or purchase a business in the United States. However, as adjudication standards evolve, applicants and attorneys alike are noticing a stronger emphasis on one critical factor: the marginality requirement.

In a recent discussion between Angie Rupert, founder of Rupert Law Group, and Marianella, Partner at Joorney, the two explored 2025 trends, common pitfalls, and practical steps to build strong, evidence-based business plans that meet the E-2 visa criteria.

Understanding the E-2 Marginality Requirement

As Angie explained, two key reasons continue to drive E-2 visa denials: lack of substantial investment and failure to meet the real and operating marginality requirement.

“The two main reasons for denials in most E2s are either going to be lack of substantial investment or the real and operating marginality requirement,” Angie noted. “Some consulates will kind of mix and match those two requirements or conflate the terms a little bit. That’s one of the trends that we’re seeing in 2025, a real emphasis on the marginality requirement.”

The marginality test essentially examines whether the business will generate more than enough income to support the investor and contribute meaningfully to the U.S. economy.

The Role of a Strong Business Plan

For new or early-stage E-2 businesses, the business plan remains one of the most crucial documents in the application package.

“An E2 business plan is a little bit different than your usual business plan,” Marianella explained. “First of all, your audience is the United States government. And second of all, they want to know if you meet the E2 requirements. They are less interested in some of the things that maybe investors might be interested in.”

Joorney’s process starts with a detailed questionnaire that allows each plan to be fully customized to the investor’s specific business. Marianella emphasized that the more details applicants provide, the more accurately the plan can be tailored.

“No two dog grooming businesses are going to be exactly the same,” she said. “The more details you’re able to provide in the questionnaire, the more specific the business plan is going to be to you.”

Evidence-Based Projections: Backing Numbers with Data

One of the most common weaknesses in E-2 business plans is unsupported financial projections.

“Consulates really want evidence-based numbers, not just like, ‘I think we’ll make $280,000 this year. I think we’ll make $7 million this year,’ based on what?” Angie noted.

To ensure credibility, Joorney incorporates market research, industry averages, and reliable databases into every plan, Marianella explained.

“So we have a lot of sources for that. We do market research that includes looking for average revenues of those particular businesses. Among other things, we include five-year projections of those financials because immigration wants to see growth,” she said.

This evidence-based approach helps align expectations between attorneys, clients, and adjudicators while reducing the risk of inconsistencies.

Collaboration Between Attorneys, Clients, and Business Plan Writers

A recurring theme in the discussion was the importance of collaboration.

“The business plan isn’t something written in isolation,” Angie said. “It’s a team effort between the investor, the attorney, and the business plan writers. Each brings key information to the table.”

Marianella agreed. “We try to make sure that once we receive those numbers, that they have enough substance. Where did these numbers come from? Are there similar businesses in the area? We encourage feedback and revisions. Clients know their businesses best, and their input helps ensure accuracy. Our goal is to find a balance between their projections, market data, and the immigration lawyer’s strategy.”

This cooperative process ensures that final plans are both accurate and strategic, satisfying immigration criteria while reflecting the investor’s real business vision.

Striking the Right Balance: Conservative Yet Growth-Oriented

As both experts emphasized, successful E-2 business plans must strike a delicate balance between realism and ambition. Applicants sometimes overestimate growth, they will predict five offices and millions in revenue – and five years later, they have one office and modest profits. That discrepancy can create renewal challenges.

Conversely, overly modest projections can also hurt the case. Marianella explained that the plan needs to demonstrate both viability and growth potential.

“The growth shows how you’re going to get that revenue, and it needs to be coming from somewhere,” she said. “It’s about finding that sweet spot – realistic but confident, conservative but scalable.”

Trends in 2025: Marginality Under the Microscope

According to both Angie and Marianella, consular officers are now reviewing marginality more closely than ever.

“Recently we’ve had a couple of different clients that did lessons-based business,” Angie said. “One was piano lessons, one was ice skating lessons. One was approved, one was not. And I believe that a lot of that had to do with marginality.”

Marianella added that adjudicators are looking for evidence of sustainability. “They want to see not only that you can support yourself but also clear plans for hiring and revenue growth. Marketing activities, community outreach, and partnerships all help prove scalability.”

Timing and Accuracy Matter

Both experts advised to begin the business plan process only once the business details are finalized.

“It’s best to wait until you know exactly what business you’re buying or starting,” Angie explained. “If the data is too early, it goes stale – and immigration officers expect current, accurate information.”

Marianella emphasized that Joorney offers revisions but accuracy depends on timing. “Once clients have made concrete decisions – location, structure, key hires – that’s the perfect moment to start the plan,” she said.

Key Takeaways

For E-2 visa applicants and attorneys supporting them, 2025 brings both opportunity and scrutiny. A well-prepared, evidence-backed business plan can make the difference between approval and denial.

Key insights from the discussion include:

  • The marginality requirement is under increased review in 2025.
  • Evidence-based projections with clear sourcing are essential.
  • Collaboration between attorney, applicant, and business plan writer leads to stronger cases.
  • Realistic, sustainable growth projections outperform overly ambitious ones.
  • Timing matters – the most effective business plans are based on finalized business details.

As Marianella concluded:

“If you’ve hired an experienced immigration lawyer like Angie Rupert, that’s half the battle. And if you partner with Joorney for your business plan, you have the other half covered.”

Watch the Full Interview

For the complete conversation between Rupert Law Group and Joorney Business Plans – including detailed discussion on marginality trends and practical E-2 strategies – watch the webinar here.

To learn more about Joorney’s E-2 Visa Business Plan Services, visit our E-2 page or contact us today.

Disclaimer: Joorney Business Plans Inc. is not a law firm nor an immigration consulting firm, and no information provided in this document should be considered as legal advice or any advice or recommendation on any immigration application program. All information provided in this document should be verified by a licensed or certified immigration professional before the reader can act on this information. As such, it is understood that Joorney Business Plans Inc. shall not be liable for any loss or damage of whatever nature (direct, indirect, consequential, or other), whether arising in contract, tort, or otherwise, which may arise as a result of your use of (or inability to use) this document, or from your use of (or failure to use) the information on this document.